Choosing the Best Python GUI Library: Comparing Tkinter, PyQt, and wxPython

Photo by Marita Kavelashvili on Unsplash

When it comes to Python GUI libraries, PyQt, Tkinter, and wxPython each have their unique strengths and trade-offs. Here’s a comparison of these three popular libraries:

1. Tkinter

• Overview: Tkinter is the standard GUI library that comes bundled with Python, making it the easiest option to start with. It’s lightweight and simple.
• Pros:
• Built-in: Comes pre-installed with Python, no additional installation required.
• Simple: Very easy to use for small applications and simple GUIs.
• Cross-Platform: Works on Windows, macOS, and Linux.
• Cons:
• Limited Features: While it’s great for simple GUIs, it’s not as feature-rich as the other two.
• Old Look: Tkinter apps tend to have a dated or less polished appearance (though there are ways to style them).
• Performance: Might not be the best for more complex or graphically intensive apps.

2. PyQt (or PySide)

• Overview: PyQt is a set of Python bindings for the Qt application framework, which is widely used in the industry for developing cross-platform applications. PySide is the official binding of Qt for Python.
• Pros:
• Rich Feature Set: Qt is a fully-fledged framework that provides advanced features like support for 2D graphics, threading, networking, and more.
• Modern Look: PyQt apps typically have a polished, professional appearance.
• Cross-Platform: PyQt works seamlessly across Windows, macOS, and Linux.
• Documentation & Community: Excellent resources and a strong community of developers.
• Cons:
• Learning Curve: PyQt is more complex than Tkinter and can be overwhelming for beginners.
• License: PyQt is available under GPL or a commercial license, meaning you might need to pay for a commercial license if you plan to release a proprietary application (PySide is LGPL-licensed, which is more permissive).
• Size: PyQt applications are relatively large in size compared to those made with Tkinter or wxPython.

3. wxPython

• Overview: wxPython is another mature cross-platform GUI library for Python. It is a set of Python bindings for the wxWidgets C++ library.
• Pros:
• Native Look and Feel: wxPython apps look and behave like native applications on Windows, macOS, and Linux, making them feel more integrated with the system.
• Feature-Rich: wxPython has many widgets and tools for creating complex UIs.
• Cross-Platform: wxPython supports all major platforms, and the look is native to each platform.
• Cons:
• Learning Curve: While not as steep as PyQt, wxPython still requires time to get used to.
• Documentation: While good, wxPython’s documentation can be less polished than PyQt’s.
• Performance: wxPython can be slower than PyQt for more complex applications.

Summary

• For Beginners: Tkinter is the best choice for simple applications or those new to Python GUI development, especially since it comes bundled with Python.
• For Feature-Rich Applications: PyQt (or PySide) is ideal for more complex, professional-looking applications, especially if you need advanced features and custom widgets.
• For Native Feel: wxPython is great for developers who want their application to feel truly native across all platforms.

Ultimately, your choice will depend on the complexity of your project and your familiarity with GUI development. If you’re just starting out, Tkinter is a good way to get your feet wet, while PyQt or wxPython will be better choices for larger, more sophisticated applications.