PyQt vs PySide: A Comprehensive Comparison for Python Qt Development

Photo by Stefan Cosma on Unsplash

PyQt and PySide are both Python bindings for the Qt framework, allowing Python developers to create cross-platform applications with the Qt toolkit. They provide similar functionality but differ in licensing, community, and some implementation details. Here’s a detailed comparison:

1. PyQt

• Overview: PyQt is a set of Python bindings for the Qt application framework. It allows Python developers to create desktop and mobile applications with a native look and feel using Qt. PyQt is developed by Riverbank Computing.
• Key Features:
• Bindings for Qt: PyQt provides bindings to a wide range of Qt features, including graphics, networking, multithreading, and more.
• Cross-Platform: Works on major platforms like Windows, macOS, Linux, and supports mobile platforms (though mobile support is less mature).
• Rich Set of Widgets: Provides a large set of widgets and tools for building complex UIs.
• QML Support: PyQt supports QML for declarative UI design.
• Qt Designer: PyQt integrates well with Qt Designer for drag-and-drop GUI design.
• Pros:
• Feature-Rich: PyQt provides access to the full Qt framework, making it ideal for building both simple and complex applications.
• Stable: PyQt has been around for a long time and is considered stable with a mature ecosystem.
• Documentation: PyQt has extensive documentation, including tutorials and examples.
• Good Community Support: PyQt has a large community of developers and users.
• Cons:
• Licensing: PyQt is licensed under GPL or a commercial license. This means that if you are developing closed-source software, you will need to purchase a commercial license. The GPL license requires you to open-source your project if you distribute it.
• Complexity: PyQt can be complex, especially for developers unfamiliar with Qt or C++ concepts, as it exposes a lot of the low-level Qt functionality.

2. PySide

• Overview: PySide is the official Python binding for the Qt toolkit, developed by The Qt Company (the creators of Qt). It is a more recent alternative to PyQt and is often considered the “official” Python binding for Qt.
• Key Features:
• Bindings for Qt: Like PyQt, PySide provides Python bindings to the full Qt framework, including the Qt widgets, QML, graphics, and more.
• Cross-Platform: PySide works on all major platforms, including Windows, macOS, Linux, and mobile platforms.
• QML Support: PySide supports QML for building modern, dynamic UIs.
• Qt Creator Integration: PySide integrates well with Qt Creator, which is the official IDE for Qt development.
• Pros:
• Licensing: PySide is available under the LGPL (Lesser General Public License), which is more permissive than PyQt’s GPL or commercial license. This makes PySide a better choice for closed-source commercial applications without the need for a commercial license.
• Official Bindings: PySide is developed by the Qt Company, making it the official and more “supported” choice for Python developers working with Qt.
• Stability: Since it is backed by the Qt Company, PySide often receives updates and bug fixes alongside Qt releases.
• Cons:
• Community and Documentation: While PySide has good documentation and community support, it is not as large or as mature as PyQt’s. However, the gap is closing over time.
• Development Progress: PySide has sometimes lagged behind PyQt in terms of feature availability or bug fixes, as it is typically updated in sync with the Qt releases (which are usually slower than the updates for PyQt).

Comparison Summary

When to Choose Which:

• Choose PyQt if:
• You need the largest community support and mature ecosystem.
• You are developing open-source software or can comply with the GPL license.
• You are comfortable with its more complex licensing for closed-source applications.
• Choose PySide if:
• You prefer the LGPL license for your project, especially if you need to develop closed-source commercial applications without purchasing a commercial license.
• You want to use the official Qt bindings that are maintained by the Qt Company.
• You are looking for an option that is growing rapidly and has good integration with Qt Creator.

Final Thoughts:

• Both PyQt and PySide are excellent choices for building cross-platform applications using Python and Qt.
• PyQt has been around longer and has a larger community, but PySide offers a more permissive license (LGPL) and is the official set of bindings provided by the Qt Company.
• For closed-source projects, PySide is often the better choice due to its LGPL license, whereas PyQt requires a commercial license for closed-source development.